The Rambam in hilchos teshuva chapter 5 explains that through the use of knowledge, one will come to the conclusion that we have bechira, it is not somthing that chazal needed to teach us. However, regarding Yiras Shamayim, one may have thought otherwise. Chazal is therefore teaching us a chiddush when they said that we are in control of Yiras Shamayim.
Yona asked what about the end of the pasuk, loving Hashem? If we are to understand that Yiras Shamayim is the only thing which is in our control, then Ahavas Hashem is not. When it comes to loving Hashem, one can have all the proper thoughts and do the right actions but whether or not one will feel of love, is b'yiday shamayim. However, this is not the case with yiras shamayim.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
A I learned with R. Dovid many years ago in R. Wolbe's Beis ha'Mussar - it is mashma in Rambam's Sefer ha'mitzvos, Aseh 3 ("sh'tavo ha'ahavah b'hechreach")that ahavas Hashem is in our hands.
ReplyDeleteI think that we have to define our terms. Yir'as Hashem has a number of definitions (fear of punishment, awe, acting in a way that the world is no hefker, ect.). We have to figure out what we are talking about.
ReplyDelete